« You can't beat a bit of Bulli (4 days in Western Andalucia) | Main | The future is yellow – but it’s also brown, white, black, etc »

Sat-Nav is for wimps

By El Cid
The commercial bombardment is ceaseless and already we have a strong candidate for the must-have gadget for dads this Christmas -- Satellite Navigation for the car.
But mum and kids take note: thanks, but no thanks.
Call me a luddite but there is something distinctly ignoble about Sat-Nav.
It's not just an ubersexual male thing; I'm sure many women agree with me.
But any-self-respecting man prides himself on his mastery of routes.
We can't all be London cabbies but all true Londoners must have a bit of knowledge. And the older we get the more knowledge we accumulate.
That knowledge includes a flexible array of ready alternatives, which take into account such imponderables as traffic, time of day, mood, and include a capacity for some intelligent second-guessing. I'm still learning even now and I take pleasure in that fact.
'Cool, so if I turn right off The Highway up Cannon Street I can bypass the traffic around Tower Bridge. On the other hand, I tried that last Sunday afternoon and the junction with Commercial Road was a bit sticky, so maybe not.'
'So you wanna go to Muswell Hill from Manor House? This might sound odd but you need to head off in completely the wrong direction in order to avoid the horrendous traffic on Green Lanes and around Finsbury Park. Go east into Tottenham, cut up St Anns, up Black Boy, Downhills, then back west over the top of Wood Green and around the back of Ally Pally. You'll be there in half the time.'
'The Camberwell route to Tulse Hill is good coz you can by-pass Brixton. But the high road is chocka on a Saturday during the day so it's often better to veer left at the Oval as if heading towards Brixton and then turning left at the petrol station, twisting around the back of Loughborough Junction, Herne Hill and Brockwell Park.'
And so on and so on.
I recall hundreds of conversations with friends and family -- sometimes jovial, sometimes heated, but always gratifying -- over the best way to get somewhere.
You think a Tom-Tom sitting on the dashboard is good for the soul or for that part of the brain dealing with spacial awareness? I think not. Like pizza or foie-gras, you can have too much of good thing.
Don't get me wrong. I'm not anti-technology. I do believe in progress.
For example, there's no way that I could ever part with my trusty power drill and go back to screwing by hand -- my office-nancy palms struggle with the blisters.
I also see the benefits of Sat-Nav for newcomers to our big city, including migrant mini-cabbers, and when travelling long distances or abroad.
But just as we lament the passing of basic maths skills because of the advent of the calculator, we may one day come to regret the passing of other ancient problem-solving skills, such as getting from A to B.
Still, if it means luddites like me can retain a competitive advantage because all the Sat-Nav lemmings are following the most obvious route, then bully for us.

November 20, 2005 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834202ac553ef00d83496d56669e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Sat-Nav is for wimps:

Comments

The real reason sat-nav is not kosher is because it is every man's god-given right to drive around for hours lost, insisting he knows the way, even in a city he has never driven in and refusing to stop to ask for directions.

Posted by: Leicester boy | Nov 22, 2005 10:29:20 PM

yeah, i agree, sat-nav is a bit girly. What's wrong with knowing your way around?

Posted by: dolly | Nov 22, 2005 10:25:48 PM

Friend of mine had faaamlee over from deeepest styx (Kent). They had to get someone from Forest Gate to Victoria coach station on a Sunday afternoon. "No prob" the out-of-towner stated. "Sat-Nav says 31 minutes". My friend explained that he'd be lucky to get there in an hour.Advice ignored.Consquently the coach was missed, and the next available coach wasn't leaving until Monday evening. Sat Nav? Chuck 'em in the bin and buy a map.

Posted by: Mark | Nov 21, 2005 9:00:37 PM

Our car’s got it built in and now we argue about other things rather than where we’re going.

I do agree, however, that if you know your way round London, they end to be a hindrance rather than a help thanks their uncanny ability to find the busiest roads and make sure you hit them at peak times. Out of London, they're a godsend, plug in the destination postcode, sit back and enjoy the drive and more importantly, the fact that there's someone else to blame when you get lost.

Posted by: rob | Nov 21, 2005 11:34:32 AM

Good point, very interesting, broadly agree, although I have to say that any technology which threatens to make 'the knowledge' redundant and send the black cab mafia packing off back to essex can only be good

Posted by: Roger Dodge | Nov 21, 2005 11:30:00 AM

aargh - but do your natural ninja senses locate POI? That being 'points of interest' i.e. petrol stations, hotels in the area, tourist attractions, parking etc.
There's more to the satellite P than just roads, inaudible Japanese narrative and pixelated 2D graphics you know..

Posted by: melly's bird | Nov 21, 2005 11:29:52 AM

Post a comment